Boxing pound-for-pound rankings: Josh Taylor drops after controversial victory
Josh Taylor gets knocked down but still manages to grab the win and defend his titles against Jack Catterall. (1:02)
Josh Taylor made a big statement in May, when he defeated Jose Ramirez to win all four major junior welterweight belts. Taylor had another opportunity to show the world that his victory wasn’t just a one-off this past weekend, when he faced mandatory challenger Jack Catterall. But while Taylor won a split decision, many boxing experts thought Catterall deserved the nod. Even the British Boxing Board of Control announced days after the bout it would investigate the scoring.
Some of our panelists also believed Taylor lost the fight, prompting them to drop him down the rankings. Some took Taylor completely out of their lists.
ESPN senior boxing writer Mike Coppinger dropped Taylor from his P4P rankings altogether, saying it’s hard to keep him even after the victory.
“Taylor is undoubtedly a pound-for-pound talent, but it’s tough to justify a top-10 ranking after such a lackluster performance against an untested challenger,” Coppinger said. “Catterall might prove to be an elite boxer with time, and the decision wasn’t the robbery some suggest. Perhaps Taylor was weight-drained and will return to form fighting one division above at 147 pounds. He’ll have ample opportunity to reestablish himself as one of the best pound-for-pound boxers in the world at welterweight.”
ESPN writer Michael Rothstein agrees, noting he thought Taylor lost the fight.
“Taylor may still be an undisputed champion, but after seeing him fight against Catterall, his pound-for-pound ranking took a major hit,” Rothstein said. “Now that he’s talking about going up a weight class too, he needs to show some dominance at 147 before I would consider ranking him again.
“Taylor is a good fighter, but there are many good fighters in boxing.”
Did that mediocre performance cost Taylor his spot in the top 10? Our panel of Mike Coppinger, Andre Ward, Tim Bradley, Joe Tessitore, Michael Rothstein, Eric Raskin, Teddy Atlas, Nick Parkinson, Ben Baby, Eric Woodyard, Claudia Trejos, Michelle Joy Phelps, Kel Dansby, Bernardo Pilatti, Charles Moynihan and Salvador Rodriguez share their votes.
More rankings: Divisional rankings and ESPN’s women’s pound-for-pound rankings.
Note: Results are through March 2.
RECORD: 56-1-2, 38 KOs
DIVISION: Super middleweight (undisputed champion)
LAST FIGHT: W (TKO11) Caleb Plant, Nov. 6
NEXT FIGHT: May 7 vs. Dmitry Bivol
RECORD: 38-0, 29 KOs
DIVISION: Welterweight (champion)
LAST FIGHT: W (TKO10) Shawn Porter, Nov. 20
NEXT FIGHT: TBA
RECORD: 21-0, 18 KOs
DIVISION: Bantamweight (unified champion)
LAST FIGHT: W (KO8) Aran Dipaen, Dec. 14
NEXT FIGHT: TBD
RECORD: 19-0, 13 KOs
DIVISION: Heavyweight (unified champion)
LAST FIGHT: W (UD12) Anthony Joshua, Sept. 25
NEXT FIGHT: TBA vs. Anthony Joshua
RECORD: 31-0-1, 22 KOs
DIVISION: Heavyweight (champion)
LAST FIGHT: W (KO11) Deontay Wilder, Oct. 9
NEXT FIGHT: April 23 vs. Dillian Whyte
RECORD: 27-0, 21 KOs
DIVISION: Welterweight (unified champion)
LAST FIGHT: W (UD12) Danny Garcia, Dec. 5, 2020
NEXT FIGHT: April 16 vs. Yordenis Ugas
RECORD: 16-2, 11 KOs
DIVISION: Lightweight
LAST FIGHT: W (UD12) Richard Commey, Dec. 11
NEXT FIGHT: TBA
RECORD: 42-3, 28 KOs
DIVISION: Junior bantamweight (unified champion)
LAST FIGHT: W (SD12) Roman “Chocolatito” Gonzalez, March 13
NEXT FIGHT: TBA
RECORD: 19-0, 13 KOs
DIVISION: Junior welterweight (undisputed champion)
LAST FIGHT: W (SD12) Jack Catterall, Feb. 26
NEXT FIGHT: TBA
RECORD: 26-0, 24 KOs
DIVISION: Lightweight (titlist)
LAST FIGHT: W (UD12) Isaac Cruz, Dec. 5
NEXT FIGHT: TBA
The rankings are based on a descending points system, with a first-place vote receiving 10 points, a second-place vote receiving nine points and so on. A tie goes to the fighter with the highest ranking and then the one with the most votes at that ranking.
Others receiving votes: George Kambosos Jr. (16), Artur Beterbiev (9), Roman “Chocolatito” Gonzalez (5), Gennadiy Golovkin (3), Teofimo Lopez (2), Stephen Fulton (2), Shakur Stevenson (1), Jermell Charlo (1), Stephen Fulton (1), Nonito Donaire (1).
Atlas: 1. Crawford, 2. Alvarez, 3. Inoue, 4. Usyk, 5. Lomachenko, 6. Spence, 7. Fury, 8. Davis, 9. Estrada, 10. Beterbiev
Bradley: 1. Crawford, 2. Alvarez, 3. Usyk, 4. Inoue, 5. Lomachenko, 6. Kambosos, 7. Fury, 8. Spence, 9. Davis, 10. Donaire
Ward: 1. Crawford, 2. Alvarez, 3. Fury, 4. Usyk, 5. Spence, 6. Inoue, 7. Lomachenko, 8. Estrada, 9. Taylor, 10. Davis
Coppinger: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Inoue, 4. Fury, 5. Usyk, 6. Spence, 7. Lomachenko, 8. Gonzalez, 9. Estrada, 10. Estrada
Tessitore: 1. Crawford, 2. Alvarez, 3. Inoue, 4. Usyk, 5. Lomachenko, 6. Fury, 7. Spence, 8. Estrada, 9. Taylor, 10. Stevenson
Parkinson: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Inoue, 4. Fury, 5. Usyk, 6. Kambosos, 7. Lomachenko, 8. Spence, 9. Taylor, 10. Estrada
Baby: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Usyk, 4. Inoue, 5. Fury, 6. Spence, 7. Estrada, 8. Lomachenko, 9. Fulton, 10. Davis
Rothstein: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Inoue, 4. Fury, 5. Usyk, 6. Spence, 7. Lomachenko, 8. Davis, 9. Estrada, 10. Kambosos
Woodyard: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Fury, 4. Inoue, 5. Spence, 6. Usyk, 7. Lomachenko, 8. Taylor, 9. Davis, 10. Kambosos
Raskin: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Inoue, 4. Spence, 5. Fury, 6. Usyk, 7. Lomachenko, 8. Estrada, 9. Gonzalez, 10. Beterbiev
Trejos: 1. Alvarez, 2. Usyk, 3. Fury, 4. Crawford, 5. Inoue, 6. Taylor, 7. Beterbiev, 8. Spence, 9. Lomachenko, 10. Estrada
Phelps: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Spence, 4. Inoue, 5. Usyk, 6. Taylor, 7. Fury, 8. Kambosos, 9. Lopez, 10. Charlo
Dansby: 1. Alvarez, 2. Usyk, 3. Crawford, 4. Inoue, 5. Fury, 6. Spence, 7. Lomachenko, 8. Davis, 9. Beterbiev, 10. Taylor
Moynihan: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Spence, 4. Inoue, 5. Usyk, 6. Fury, 7. Lomachenko, 8. Golovkin, 9. Estrada, 10. Kambosos
Pilatti: 1. Crawford, 2. Inoue, 3. Spence, 4. Alvarez, 5. Lomachenko, 6. Fury, 7. Estrada, 8. Usyk, 9. Davis, 10. Taylor
Rodriguez: 1. Alvarez, 2. Crawford, 3. Fury, 4. Inoue, 5. Usyk, 6. Lomachenko, 7. Spence, 8. Taylor, 9. Estrada, 10. Davis
First place: Alvarez (11), Crawford (5)
Second place: Crawford (9), Alvarez (4), Usyk (2), Inoue (1)
Third place: Inoue (6), Fury (4), Spence (3), Usyk (2), Crawford (1)
Fourth place: Inoue (7), Usyk (3), Fury (3), Alvarez (1), Crawford (1), Spence (1)
Fifth place: Usyk (6), Lomachenko (4), Fury (3), Spence (2), Inoue (1)
Sixth place: Spence (5), Fury (3), Usyk (2), Taylor (2), Kambosos (2), Inoue (1), Lomachenko (1)
Seventh place: Lomachenko (8), Fury (3), Spence (2), Estrada (2), Beterbiev (1)
Eighth place: Spence (3), Estrada (3), Davis (3), Taylor (2), Usyk (1), Lomachenko (1), Kambosos (1), Golovkin (1), Gonzalez (1),
Ninth place: Estrada (5), Taylor (3), Davis (3), Lomachenko (1), Fulton (1), Beterbiev (1), Lopez (1), Gonzalez (1)
10th place: Davis (3), Kambosos (3), Beterbiev (3), Estrada (2), Taylor (2), Jermelll Charlo (1), Stevenson (1), Donaire (1)