A new connection between topology and quantum entanglement
“Our work ties two big ideas together,” says Charles Kane, the Christopher H. Browne Distinguished Professor of Physics in Penn’s School of Arts & Sciences. “It’s a conceptual link between topology, which is a way of characterizing the universal features that quantum states have, and entanglement, which is a way in which quantum states can exhibit non-local correlations, where something that happens in one point in space is correlated with something that happens in another part in space. What we’ve found is a situation where those concepts are tightly intertwined.”
The seed for exploring this connection came during the long hours Kane spent in his home office during the pandemic, pondering new ideas. One train of thought had him envisioning the classic textbook image of the Fermi surface of copper, which represents the metal’s potential electron energies. It’s a picture every physics student sees, and one with which Kane was highly familiar.
“Of course, I learned about that picture back in the 1980s but had never thought about it as describing a topological surface,” Kane says.
A classic way of thinking about topological surfaces, says Kane, is to consider the difference between a donut and a sphere. What’s the difference? A single hole. Topology considers these generalizable properties of a surface, which are not changed by deformation. Under this principle, a coffee cup and a donut would have the same topological property.
Considering the Fermi surface of copper as a topological object, then, the associated number of holes it possesses is four, a figure also known as a genus. Once Kane began thinking of the Fermi surface in this way, he wondered whether a relationship could exist between the genus and quantum entanglement.
To further investigate that potential connection, Kane involved his graduate student Pok Man Tam and Martin Claassen, an assistant professor of physics at Penn who has focused on quantum entanglement in his work. Together, they derived a mathematical relationship between the genus of the Fermi surface and a measure of quantum entanglement called the mutual information. The mutual information characterizes the correlations that can occur in disparate regions of space that meet at a single point. A number known as the Euler characteristic, which is closely related to the genus, provided the precise connection between the two.
The researchers established that the relationship between topology and entanglement held in a simple metal system, with electrons moving independently of one another, then extended their analysis to show that the connection was also present even when electrons interacted with greater complexity.
And while the theoretical work was done on metals, Kane believes it will extend to other materials as well, such as those that involve very strong interactions between electrons.
“What this may allow us to do is devise new ways of thinking about phases of matter that we don’t understand very well and don’t have as many tools for exploring,” Kane says. “People are trying to figure out how to leverage quantum mechanics to take advantage of quantum information. In order to do that, you have to understand how quantum mechanics manifests itself when you have many degrees of freedom. That’s a very hard problem, and this work is nudging us along in that direction.”
In follow-up work, Kane and colleagues hope to design experiments that continue to explore the newfound link, perhaps devising a new technique to measure the topological genus and a way to probe the structure of quantum entanglement.
Charles Kane is the Christopher H. Browne Distinguished Professor of Physics in the University of Pennsylvania School of Arts & Sciences.
Kane’s coauthors, both from Penn’s Department of Physics, were Pok Man Tam, a graduate student, and Martin Claassen, an assistant professor.
The study was supported in part by the Simons Foundation.