An inside look at Indian students in Canada
Credit to Author: Douglas Todd| Date: Mon, 09 Dec 2019 18:51:23 +0000
Addressing professors by first names is strange for most. The cold weather can get some down. Having to follow rigorous rules against plagiarism and data manipulation can be an eye opener. So are frank discussions about sexuality and LGBQT freedoms.
Those are some of the revealing insights that two international students from India have put together in an article, below, on the challenges faced by many of the large group of often-socially conservative students who are coming from India to study in Canada, where they find academic rigour to be much higher.
The wide-ranging guest post is co-written by Sumeet Sekhon, who arrived in Canada in 2008. Sekhon is a University of B.C. Okanagan postdoctoral research fellow whose PhD looks at marginalised women in India. She specializes in gender, caste and rural economic development.
Co-writer Navjotpal (Nav) Kaur is a PhD candidate in sociology at Memorial University of Newfoundland. Her research interests include sociology of gender, masculinities, international migration and caste.
Here is their probing article:
We came to Canada from Punjab in India to pursue higher education. Sumeet came to Canada for a master’s degree, and stayed to finish her PhD as well, while Nav came to Canada to pursue a PhD after having spent almost two decades in the Indian education system
Sumeet Sekhon is a postdoctoral research and teaching fellow at UBC Okanagan [PNG Merlin Archive]
Below, we chronicle the struggles we faced in transitioning and adapting to the Canadian higher education environment.
We also highlight the differences in higher education between India and Canada, and provide some solutions that can be used by students, as well as Canadian universities, to ensure that the transitions between the two countries and education systems are successful.
This article is topical given the steep rise in the number of Indian international students in Canada – this number more than tripled in three years.
Culture shock
Many institutions provide resources to help international students transition from one education system to the other.
However, culture shock – which highlights the potential of a disoriented disposition for international students owing to the differences between the two cultures – often manifests in subtle ways that can be overlooked by the universities, such as with regards to student-professor relationships and peer relations.
The informality and friendliness of the interaction between students and teachers might seem strange to students from India, as it did to both of us. In India, owing to the age-old concept of the teacher as guru (master/teacher) students are expected to display a great degree of respect towards the teacher.
Moreover, the colonial hangover in education in India places an obligation on students to refer to their teachers as “sir” and “madam”.
Additionally according to Indian cultural norms, it is considered disrespectful to address your seniors – in terms of age or stature – by their first name. However, in Canada, it is very normal to address teachers or professors by their first names.
Addressing the supervisors and other faculty members by their first names felt quite awkward in the beginning, but we gradually understood that the Canadian professors were treating us as equals and colleagues. Informal interactions with professors over dinners and other social events were particularly helpful in this regard.
Ideological shock over sex and gender discourses
This is another significant but less talked about issue. In Canadian universities, there is an open and healthy discourse around gender and sexuality.
However, for international students from conservative cultures, where these issues are often shrouded in silence, this discourse can be quite perplexing and disorienting. We both recall being surprised, albeit pleasantly, by the casual use of words about sexual identity, such as LGBTQ+, non-binary gender, gender fluid etc.
Given that Canada attracts a significant number of international students from India and other conservative countries, Canadian universities and colleges would benefit from engaging such students in discussions around topics such as gender and sexuality. This initiative would also allow the students to get acclimatised to the university environment more quickly.
Seasonal affective disorder (SAD) in a northern climate
“So this is what -30 degrees Celsius feels like,” Sumeet thought while waiting for a bus on a bitter, grey January morning in Calgary. Never having experienced temperatures below zero degrees celsius, the winters in Canada were not only physically uncomfortable, but they also took a significant toll on mental health.
It took three winters to learn that this could have been a mild form of seasonal affective disorder (SAD), also known as winter or seasonal depression.
Indeed, some reports show that international students from warm countries are more susceptible to SAD.
Academic integrity and plagiarism
Having enjoyed significant academic success in India, we did not expect to find it difficult to maintain A-level grades in Canada. But at first, we both struggled to understand the concepts of plagiarism and academic integrity.
Indeed, we have nearly got into trouble due to a lack of citations and poor paraphrasing in term papers. The research culture, particularly in the social sciences, is very different in India and Canada.
In India, the lack of emphasis on developing academic writing ethics, combined with the urgency to “complete the degree”, often makes students resort to sub-par techniques even at graduate level.
Compromising the quality of writing, copying and pasting text, and writing vaguely or convolutedly are among the many practices that most Indian students adopt without even realising that they are indulging in unethical behaviour.
Except for a few islands of excellence, most Indian universities lack a healthy research culture. In a recent report, the University Grants Commission – a central body charged with the coordination and maintenance of higher education in India – has admitted that the overall quality of research in most Indian higher education institutions is “far from satisfactory”.
This report, as well as a paper by a senior Indian sociologist, highlights various issues, such as widespread plagiarism, data manipulation and an alarming number of publications by Indian academics in predatory journals. Some other issues are the lack of physical infrastructure, research funding and qualified faculty members.
Conclusion
Despite the considerable geographic distance – Nav is located in Newfoundland while Sumeet is in British Columbia – the similarities of their experiences speak to the challenges that Indian students are likely to face while transitioning between the two education systems.
While the issues discussed above might be taken for granted for domestic students in Canada, it is imperative to familiarize international students with the ethics of writing and doing research in Canadian universities, as well as the subtleties of the larger culture and prevalent ideologies in these universities.
– Sumeet Sekhon and Nav Kaur