Remember the late Bill Buckner for the ballplayer, not the play
Tim Kurkjian remembers the legacy of Bill Buckner and adds that his career was not defined by one error in the 1986 World Series. Buckner died Monday at the age of 69. (1:57)
Bill Buckner is one of the most underrated and unappreciated players in major league baseball history, a man whose legacy in the game will forever be misrepresented by so many.
Too many will remember him first as the guy who made one of the most famous errors in baseball history, which it was: The ball going through his legs in the 1986 World Series has been, and will be, shown as often as almost any highlight or lowlight in the game’s history.
What too many people forget is that the error occurred in Game 6, not Game 7, and the score was tied when the error was made. If he had fielded it and thrown out speedy Mookie Wilson at first, the Red Sox would not necessarily have won the World Series for the first time since 1918 — the game would have gone to the 11th inning. The Red Sox also had a chance to win the Series in Game 7, but they lost a 3-0 lead. Too much fault goes on Buckner.
Played for: Dodgers (1969-76), Cubs (1977-84), Red Sox (1984-87, 1990), Angels (1987-88) and Kansas City Royals (1988-89).
Career line: .289 average, 2,715 hits, 498 doubles, 174 home runs and 1,208 RBI in 2,517 major league games.
Noteworthy: 1980 NL batting title (.324), 1981 All-Star. Buckner made his big league debut at 19 years old and retired at the age of 40.
“I understand that,” Buckner told me many years later. “I had to be strong enough to take it.”
Here’s how we should remember Bill Bucker: He had more hits than Ted Williams as well as many others, including Ernie Banks, Steve Garvey and Manny Ramirez.
Buckner never struck out three times in any game, which is jarring given the staggering strikeout rate in today’s game. He never struck out 40 times in a season; today, guys strike out 40 times in a month.
In 1980, he won a batting title, hitting .324. He led the league in doubles twice. He could run. He was a good outfielder when he first came to the big leagues with the Dodgers at age 19, and he was a good first baseman before his legs gave way: Dave Stapleton should have been at first base in the ninth inning in Game 6.
Don Baylor, a teammate of Buckner’s on that 1986 team, once told me, “Buck cared so much about winning. It crushed him that we lost that game and that Series. Late in his career, what he did to prepare himself, on bad legs, was amazing. I’ll never forget how hard he played the game.”
Buckner was a ferocious competitor. His dear friend, Bobby Valentine, later observed of his former teammate, “Believe me, they didn’t come any tougher in this game than Buck.”